Summary: Constructive dismissal occurs when an employee resigns due to their employer’s conduct or omissions, such as harassment or contract breaches, forcing the resignation. Voluntary resignation happens when an employee chooses to leave on their own, without pressure. The key difference lies in whether the employer’s conduct contributed to the resignation.
Introduction
Did you quit your job, or were you forced to? The line between constructive dismissal and voluntary resignation is often blurred. But it’s important to recognise the difference, especially if you’re considering an unfair dismissal claim.
This guide will explain the differences between the two and outline what you need to do if your resignation was forced by your employer’s actions.
Constructive Dismissal vs. Voluntary Resignation: Difference Explained
The key difference between constructive dismissal and voluntary resignation lies in whether the resignation was truly voluntary or the result of the employer’s conduct or omission. (There is a tabulation of differences at the end of the section if you are more comfortable with that format.)
- Constructive Dismissal: This occurs when an employee feels forced to resign due to the employer’s actions, such as breaches of contract, bullying, or unsafe working conditions. The resignation may seem voluntary, but it is essentially triggered by the employer’s conduct.
- Voluntary Resignation: This happens when an employee chooses to leave their job without external pressure or coercion from the employer.
Let’s break it down.
Employer’s Role
- Constructive Dismissal: The employer’s actions (bullying, harassment, pay cuts, unsafe working conditions, or breaches of contract) force the employee to resign.
- Voluntary Resignation: The decision to leave is typically made by the employee without the employer’s involvement or pressure.
Burden of Proof
- Constructive Dismissal: The employee must prove that they did not resign voluntarily and the employer’s conduct/omission directly led to the resignation and that no reasonable alternative existed. This might involve showing a pattern of behaviour that made continued employment impossible (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 386).
- Voluntary Resignation: No burden of proof is required since the decision to leave was made by the employee. If the resignation was made in the heat of the moment or under special circumstances, it might not constitute voluntary resignation. It would be incumbent on the employee to retract the resignation as soon as possible.
Notice Period
- Constructive Dismissal: If the conditions are intolerable, the employee may be justified in leaving without giving notice, or the notice period may be waived (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 394).
- Voluntary Resignation: Employees are expected to give notice in accordance with their employment contract or workplace policy. Failure to do so could expose the employee to damages.
Entitlements
- Constructive Dismissal: Employees may be entitled to remedies such as compensation, redundancy pay, reinstatement, or other remedies depending on the nature of the dismissal (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 385) or compensation under general protection claims.
- Voluntary Resignation: Entitlements are typically limited to the final pay and any accrued leave, as per the terms of the employment contract.
Employer Liability
- Constructive Dismissal: The employer may be held liable for unfair treatment leading to the resignation. If the resignation was due to the employer’s unlawful conduct, the employee may seek compensation (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 394).
- Voluntary Resignation: The employer generally has no liability for the resignation as it was initiated by the employee.
Process
- Constructive Dismissal: Often follows complaints or grievance procedures before resignation, and the employer’s conduct must be proven to have made the environment untenable.
- Voluntary Resignation: This is usually a straightforward resignation process with no dispute.
Here’s a clean tabulation of the differences between constructive dismissal and voluntary resignation:
| Aspect | Constructive Dismissal | Voluntary Resignation |
| Definition | When an employee resigns due to the employer’s actions/omissions, such as breaches of contract, bullying, or unsafe working conditions. | When an employee chooses to leave their job willingly, without external pressure from the employer. |
| Employer’s Role | The employer’s conduct forces the employee to resign (e.g., harassment, discrimination, or significant contract breaches). | The employer is not responsible for the employee’s decision to leave. |
| Burden of Proof | The employee must prove that the employer’s conduct made resignation the only reasonable option. | No burden of proof; the employee freely decides to leave. |
| Notice Period | The notice period may be waived or shortened due to the intolerable working conditions. | The employee typically provides notice as per their contract or company policy. |
| Entitlements | May be entitled to compensation, redundancy pay, reinstatement, or other remedies, depending on the circumstances. | Entitlements are limited to final pay, unused leave, and any contractual benefits. |
| Employer Liability | The employer may be held liable for creating the conditions that forced the resignation. | The employer is typically not liable since the resignation is voluntary. |
| Process | Often follows complaints or grievance procedures before resignation. | The resignation is typically straightforward, with no disputes involved. |
| Legal Options | Employees may file a claim for unfair dismissal or breach of contract. | No claim for unfair dismissal is possible, but the employee has rights to final pay and future employment freedom. |
| Impact on Future Claims | Can lead to an unfair dismissal claim and potential remedies for the employee. | Does not support an unfair dismissal claim, but employees retain freedom to seek new employment. |
Employee Rights
Constructive Dismissal
Employees who believe they have been constructively dismissed may file a claim under the Fair Work Act 2009. However, claims must be lodged within 21 days of the resignation taking effect (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 394).
Eligibility Requirements
- At least 6 months of continuous service with a national employer (or 12 months for small businesses with fewer than 15 employees).
- The dismissal must not fall under exclusions such as genuine redundancy or serious misconduct (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 385).
- If the constructive dismissal relates to a breach of contract, employees can file a claim in the a state or federal Court dealing with contractual disputes.
The court may grant remedies, including compensation for losses or an injunction to stop further breaches (Contract Law).
Voluntary Resignation
When an employee voluntarily resigns, they typically cannot claim unfair dismissal. However, they retain important rights:
- Final Pay: Employees are entitled to receive their final pay, including any outstanding wages, accrued leave, and other contractual entitlements up to the resignation date.
- Freedom to Seek New Employment: After resignation, employees are free to pursue new job opportunities without being bound by the legal restrictions of employment disputes.
Next Steps
If you’re facing a situation where you may be forced to resign or believe you’ve been constructively dismissed, it’s vital to seek legal advice promptly. At Burke Mangan Lawyers, we can guide you through the process with clarity. We offer:
- Representation in lodging and filing your claim.
- Strategic advice tailored to your case.
- Support to achieve the best possible outcome for your situation.
Contact us today to discuss your options and take the first step in resolving your employment dispute.
FAQs
These FAQs are only a general guide, and you should seek legal advice before resigning to ascertain if you fall within the ambit of constructive dismissal. It is a narrow line between constructive dismissal and voluntary resignation.
Can I claim constructive dismissal if I was not given a reasonable opportunity to address the issues with my employer?
Yes. If your employer failed to provide you with a chance to resolve the issue or didn’t act to remedy the situation, this can strengthen your constructive dismissal claim (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 394). The resignation must be forced, and not the employee simply walking away from reasonable employer action (performance management). It is a narrow line between constructive dismissal and forced resignation (constructive dismissal).
Is constructive dismissal only applicable to employees on permanent contracts?
No. Employees on casual, part-time, or temporary contracts can also claim constructive dismissal if the employer’s actions forced them to resign. However, it will be significantly more difficult for a casual employee given the nature of their employment and unfair dismissal hurdles in the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).
Can I resign without giving notice if I’m experiencing constructive dismissal?
Yes. If the work conditions are intolerable, you may be justified in resigning without providing standard notice. This should be clearly documented and supported by evidence of the employer’s conduct (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 394). However, if the resignation is considered voluntary then you could be exposed to a damages claim.
If I was subjected to continuous verbal abuse at work, can that lead to constructive dismissal?
Yes. Continuous verbal abuse, bullying, or harassment can create an intolerable work environment. If you resigned because of this, and the employer failed to address the issue, you may have grounds for constructive dismissal (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 394).
Can I claim constructive dismissal if I resigned but my employer offered a severance package?
It depends. If the severance package was offered to avoid a claim or because your resignation was seen as forced, this may support a constructive dismissal claim. However, you must prove that the resignation was not voluntary.
Can I claim constructive dismissal if my employer reduced my hours without consulting me?
Possibly. If your employer reduces your hours significantly without agreement, which in turn affects your income or job security, it may be considered constructive dismissal (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 394).
If I resign because my job is making me sick, can that count as constructive dismissal?
Yes, if your employer’s conduct has led to physical or mental health issues, and you cannot continue working, it may qualify as constructive dismissal (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 394).
Can I claim constructive dismissal if I wasn’t formally told about changes in my role or pay?
Yes, if changes were made to your role or pay without your consent, especially if it compromised your ability to do your job, this could be considered constructive dismissal (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 394).
Can I still claim constructive dismissal if I didn’t have an official written contract?
Yes. Even without a written contract, you can claim constructive dismissal based on verbal agreements, job descriptions, or pay history. The key is proving that the employer’s actions breached your agreement or expectations (Fair Work Act 2009, Section 394).
Disclaimer
The purpose of this article is to provide a guide and overview. It is not intended to be, and should not be considered, legal advice. It is recommended that you seek legal advice in relation to your specific circumstances to determine your rights, understand time limitations, and provide you with the appropriate steps to address your circumstances. Links to third party websites are for information purposes only and we do not guarantee their contents.