Quick Summary
Proving unfair dismissal requires clear evidence, knowledge of employment laws, and a structured approach to ensure you receive justice and potential compensation.
Table of contents
- Introduction
- Legal definition
- Confirm eligibility for a claim
- Review your employment contract
- Check company policies and procedures
- Document your performance history
- Collect correspondence
- Record breaches of workplace laws
- Create timeline of events
- Obtain witness statements
- Demonstrate procedural unfairness
- Compare your case to others
- Dismissals that are unfair
- Next steps
- FAQs
Introduction
Losing your job can be devastating, especially if you believe your dismissal was unfair. Whether you were terminated without valid reasoning, not given due process, or dismissed under questionable circumstances, you need to understand your legal rights and options available to you.
Proving unfair dismissal requires clear evidence, knowledge of employment laws, and a structured approach to ensure you receive justice and potential compensation. This guide explains how to prove unfair dismissal in 11 practical steps.
1) Understand the Legal Definition of Unfair Dismissal
To determine if your case qualifies as unfair dismissal, you must first understand its legal definition under the Fair Work Act 2009.
Key Points
- The dismissal must have been harsh, unjust, or unreasonable.
- Employers must follow proper dismissal procedures.
- If you work for a small business (under 15 employees), your employer must comply with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code.
Failure to adhere to legal and procedural obligations can make a dismissal unlawful.
2) Confirm Eligibility for an Unfair Dismissal Claim
Not all dismissed employees can file a claim. To be eligible:
- You must have been employed for at least:
- 6 months (for businesses with 15+ employees).
- 12 months (for small businesses).
- You must earn below the high-income threshold (unless covered by an award or enterprise agreement).
Check Fair Work Commission (FWC) regulations to ensure you meet eligibility criteria before proceeding.
3) Review Your Employment Contract
Your employment contract, offer letters, and workplace agreements define your rights and obligations.
Look for:
- Termination clauses: Did your employer follow proper termination procedures?
- Performance expectations: Were you dismissed despite meeting contractual obligations?
- Notice periods: Were you given the required notice or compensation in lieu of notice?
A contract violation strengthens your unfair dismissal claim.
4) Check Company Policies and Procedures
Review your employer’s internal policies on:
- Performance management and disciplinary actions.
- Grievance procedures.
- Dismissal processes.
If company procedures were ignored or inconsistently applied, this may demonstrate procedural unfairness.
5) Document Your Performance History
Your work performance is indispensable in proving an unjust dismissal. Collect:
- Performance reviews and appraisals.
- Emails or feedback acknowledging your contributions.
- Evidence of promotions, bonuses, or commendations.
A strong record of good performance can counter claims of poor work conduct.
6) Collect Correspondence Related to Your Dismissal
Retain copies of all communication regarding your termination, including:
- Termination letter stating the reason for dismissal.
- Emails, memos, or meeting notes leading up to termination.
- Warnings or disciplinary actions (if applicable).
If your employer failed to issue warnings before termination, this may indicate unfair treatment.
7) Record Any Breaches of Workplace Law
Unfair dismissal may involve violations of workplace rights, such as:
- Failure to pay minimum wage or entitlements.
- Retaliation for exercising workplace rights (e.g., raising concerns about safety, requesting leave).
Collect bank statements, pay slips, or legal correspondence to support your claim.
8) Create a Detailed Timeline of Events
A chronological record of events leading to your dismissal strengthens your case.
- Dates of key incidents (warnings, performance reviews, dismissal).
- Who was involved in conversations or decisions.
- Details of procedural failures.
A clear timeline helps lawyers assess procedural fairness.
9) Obtain Witness Statements
If colleagues or supervisors witnessed unfair treatment, ask them for written statements.
- Witnesses can provide credibility to your claims.
- Ensure statements include specific incidents of unfair treatment.
Independent testimonies reinforce evidence of an unjust dismissal.
10) Demonstrate Procedural Unfairness
Your dismissal may be unfair if:
- No valid reason was provided.
- The employer ignored internal procedures.
- The company had alternative options (e.g., redeployment instead of termination).
- There was bias or discrimination in the decision-making process.
Examples of procedural unfairness:
- No proper investigation into alleged misconduct.
- No opportunity for you to respond to allegations.
- Sudden termination without prior warnings.
- Inconsistent disciplinary actions (others were treated more leniently).
Employers must justify termination with clear, fair reasoning—failure to do so can support your case.
11) Compare Your Case to Similar Workplace Situations
If other employees in similar circumstances were treated differently, this could be a sign of unfair dismissal.
- Identify other employees with comparable performance records.
- Check if others received warnings, training, or lesser penalties instead of
This helps highlight inconsistency in your employer’s decision-making.
Also read: Filing an Unfair Dismissal Claim: What You Need to Know
Dismissals that are unfair
Certain dismissals are automatically considered unfair, such as termination due to:
- Discrimination (race, gender, age, disability, pregnancy).
- Whistleblowing (reporting legal violations).
- Union involvement.
- Exercising legal rights (e.g., taking leave, requesting flexible hours).
- Refusing to engage in unlawful activities.
If any of these apply, you may have a stronger case for compensation.
Go to top
Next Steps
It’s important to immediately seek legal counsel from experienced unfair termination lawyers to assess your case’s strength. With their assistance, you can submit an unfair dismissal application to the Fair Work Commission within 21 days.
Burke Mangan Lawyers specialises in employment and family law. We are proud to offer expert assistance with unfair dismissal claims. We guide clients through the Fair Work Commission process, ensuring procedural fairness and strong representation.
Our unfair dismissal experts can help you:
- Organise and gather evidence.
- Maximise the chances of compensation for your unfair dismissal claim.
Contact us to schedule a free consultation or learn more about our services.
FAQs
Is it worth fighting an unfair dismissal case?
Yes. If your dismissal was unjustified, fighting it may lead to compensation or reinstatement. A lawyer can help strengthen your case.
How hard is it to prove unfair dismissal?
It depends on evidence and legal argumentation. Clear documentation of procedural unfairness increases the chances of success.
How long does an unfair dismissal claim take?
Conciliation can resolve cases within weeks. Formal hearings may take months, depending on the complexity of the case.
What compensation can be awarded?
You could be reinstated in your former position or financially compensated for lost wages (capped under Fair Work Laws).
What happens if I lose my unfair dismissal case?
If you lose your unfair dismissal case, you generally won’t be required to pay your employer’s legal costs. However, you cannot submit a new claim for the same dismissal.
Disclaimer
The purpose of this article is to provide a guide and overview. It is not intended to be, and should not be considered, legal advice. It is recommended that you seek legal advice in relation to your specific circumstances to determine your rights, understand time limitations, and provide you with the appropriate steps to address your circumstances. Links to third party websites are for information purposes only and we do not guarantee their contents.
